As we previously reported, the Ninth Circuit in March 2017 held
that violation of California's illustration statutes could
serve as a predicate for an Unfair Competition Law (UCL) action,
partially reversing the trial court's decision in Walker v.
Life Ins. Co. of the Southwest on the plaintiff's UCL
claims following a jury verdict for the insurer. See
Expect Focus, Volume I, March 2017.
On remand, plaintiffs filed a third amended complaint, which
alleged only that the insurer violated California's UCL by
failing to adhere to the illustration statutes. Specifically, this
iteration of the complaint alleged that the insurer: (i) provided
incomplete illustrations; (ii) portrayed nonguaranteed elements as
guaranteed; (iii) failed to define terms in language understandable
to a consumer; (iv) illustrated nonguaranteed elements not
described in the policies; and (v) used illustrations that depict
policy performance more favorable than that which could be
reasonably based