NEW LEASEHOLD INTERESTS AND GOING CONCERN TRANSFERS
The decision of the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) in the recent case
of Robinson Family Limited has called into question the
policy of HMRC that the grant of a new property interest can never
be treated as a transfer of a business or a going concern
(TOGC).
Robinson Family Limited owned a leasehold interest in a
commercial property consisting of several individual units. It
opted to tax the property and sold one unit with the benefit of a
proposed letting to a third party. No VAT was charged under the
TOGC provisions.
HMRC argued that VAT was payable on the sale of the unit on the
grounds that the creation of a new asset (the sub-lease) cannot be
a TOGC. Robinson Family Limited argued that the proposed letting of
the unit to a third party constituted a business activity and the
sale transferred that business activity to the purchaser and
effected a TOGC.