The long awaited Judgment in the
Gaines-Cooper Supreme Court Case was finally released on Wednesday
19th October 2011.
This links in with my previous
Articles of 1st March 2010 and my last Article on
Non-Residence Latest Developments on 20 September 2010 (see
previous Articles here on Mondaq).
First the outcome.
As I correctly predicted previously,
there were very few surprises in the Supreme Court decision and the
Appeals of both Davies and James and
Gaines-Cooper were both dismissed. (This might not be the
end of Litigation as Gaines-Cooper has been reported as intending
to appeal to the European Court of Justice).
The leading Judgment of the Court
was given by Lord Wilson who went into a deep and stringent
analysis of the basis on which any Appeal could be successful. That
basis would be that the statements in IR20 (the Booklet of Guidance
on Residence) deviated so substantially from the actual law and
constituted clear representations of HMRC practice,