The right to adjudicate a dispute under a construction contract
at any time is a powerful tool. Understandably, parties are
reluctant to pursue a claim if the only viable route to do so is to
commit to the time and costs of Court or arbitration proceedings. A
decision to commence a construction adjudication (under statutory
or contractual adjudication rules), where a binding and enforceable
decision can be obtained within 28 days, is a quite different and
attractive alternative.
There has however been significant potential to date to resist
enforcement of an adjudication decision concerning breach of a
settlement of a construction contract dispute. That is illogical
given that if the relevant construction contract permits a dispute
between the parties to be adjudicated, the commercial expectation
will naturally be that any dispute over settlement of that same
dispute ought also to be referable to adjudication. The recent
decision of J Murphy & Sons Ltd v W Maher and So