Whether an item is a 'fixture' or a 'fitting' is
relevant not just on the sale of a property but also in
dilapidations claims and in determining whether vacant possession
has been given for the purposes of operating a break clause.
The recent case of Earl of Cardigan v Moore [2012],
which concerned paintings in the Earl's ancestral home and
whether these could be sold separately or were part of the reality.
The case offers a reminder that whilst the distinction between
fixtures and fittings may appear simple, disputes can still
arise.
It is generally accepted as a rule that:
- fixtures are items annexed to the land; and
- fittings are those items which are free standing.
When considering whether an item has become annexed to the land
(and has therefore become a fixture), the Court in the Earl of
Cardigan's case reviewed the authorities and reconfirmed that
they must have regard to two questions: the degree of annexation
and, most importantly, the purpose of