In Herod Property Ltd v Westminster City Council [2026] EWHC 2122, the High Court dismissed a developer’s challenge to Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) notices issued after an office-to-residential conversion had been completed and the flats sold.
The case is a useful reminder that, where a developer decides for itself that no CIL is payable because existing floorspace is “in use”, it carries the risk that the collecting authority could later come to a different view, with adverse financial consequences. The case continues a line of authority highlighting the inflexibility of the CIL regime. It reinforces the value of thorough due diligence on CIL liability, undertaken by a multidisciplinary team including planning law specialists, to identify the nuances of the legislation and mitigate risk for developers and investors. In an environment where CIL exposure can materially affect project viability and value, early specialist advice remains essential.