In the recent case of MW Eat Ltd and others v James Hallam Ltd [2026] EWHC 2673 (BP), the Court declined to strike out a negligence claim against an insurance broker.
However, it ordered the Claimants to amend their case to explain the alternative insurance arrangements they alleged they would have obtained had the broker advised them properly. For brokers and their professional indemnity insurers, the decision provides some helpful guidance on what a claimant must address when alleging better insurance cover should have been obtained.
The Claim
The claim concerns business interruption losses suffered by MW Eat, a restaurant operator, during the COVID-19 pandemic. Its business interruption cover, arranged by James Hallam, contained: