The recent CJEU judgment in Sky v SkyKick confirms that
a trade mark cannot be declared invalid on the basis that terms in
the specification lack clarity or precision. It also confirms that
broad specifications could only be deemed as applied for in bad
faith where there is clear evidence that the applicant either
intended to (1) dishonestly undermine third parties' interests
or (2) acquire an exclusive right for purposes outside of a trade
mark's function.
Background
In a long-running trade mark dispute, Sky sued SkyKick for trade
mark infringement in relation to a handful of its SKY marks.
SkyKick denied infringement and counterclaimed for a declaration
that Sky's marks were wholly/partially invalid. Mr Justice
Arnold, as he was then, presided over the case in the English High
Court, delivering a long and thorough judgment before making a
preliminary reference on three key issues to the CJEU.