Back in October, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second
Circuit issued a Summary Order (no precedential effect) in a
Hurricane Sandy storm surge coverage dispute. The court reversed
summary judgment in favor of the insurer and remanded the case back
to the district court to assess whether an endorsement's
anti-concurrent causation clause conflicts with or creates an
ambiguity concerning a flood exclusion. The struggle to articulate
coverage or non-coverage for storm surge continues.
In Madelaine Chocolate Novelties,
Inc. v. Great Northern Ins. Co., No. 17-3396-cv (2d Cir.
Oct. 23, 2018), the court was faced with an all-risks policy with a
twist. Typically, an all-risks policy covers all property risks,
except for those excluded (the Company will pay for damage or
direct physical loss to a building or personal property caused by
or resulting from a peril not otherwise excluded). Here, there was
an exclusion for flood, which included rising and overflowing
harbors