This Week's Caselaw
Royal & Sun Alliance v Rolls-Royce
Whether a stay should be granted and whether Florida was
the appropriate forum to hear an insurance dispute
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2010/1869.html
The insured, an English company, commenced proceedings against
its English insurers in Florida. It sought a declaration that it
was entitled to an indemnity under various insurance policies. The
insurers then commenced proceedings in England, asserting that they
were not liable to the insured. The relevant policies did not
contain an exclusive jurisdiction clause.
In Owusu v Jackson [2005], it was held that if an
English court is first seised of proceedings against a defendant
domiciled in England, it cannot stay those proceedings in favour of
a non-Member State court (although the English court can grant a
stay if there is an exclusive jurisdiction clause). However, the
position remains unclear where (as in this case) foreign
proceedings are