This article considers three contrasting decisions
relating to road traffic accident claims.
Whilst, for obvious reasons, insurers and practitioners will
seek the comfort of established precedent in assessing claims,
inevitably many cases turn on their own facts. This is particularly
so in claims which arise following road traffic accidents. Three
recent decisions highlight the contrasting approach that can be
taken in road traffic accident claims.
In Ali v D'Brass (Court of Appeal, November 2011)
the claimant appealed against the dismissal of his claim for
personal injury. The claimant had been driving on a dual
carriageway at about 35-40mph when he braked negligently, when
there was no hazard. The defendant had been travelling about half a
car's length behind. The claim was initially dismissed on the
basis that the accident occurred because the claimant had braked
for no good reason. The Court of Appeal, however, considered that,
even though the claimant had