Depending upon where you sit in the market, reservation of
rights may be regarded as a matter of best practice or a source of
frustration.
Reservations are typically issued by insurers on notification of
a claim (especially when the scope of the notification is unclear),
when there is a specific concern about coverage or
misrepresentation/non-disclosure or when a contractual right has to
be exercised (such as inspection). The rationale for their issue
under English law is that there is virtually no legal downside for
the insurer and they reduce the risk of loss of coverage or
avoidance rights through waiver by election or estoppel
(affirmation).
Frustration at their receipt stems from the fact that, in legal
terms, the insured can do little but continue pursuing their claim.
They can also be viewed by brokers and the insured as an aggressive
act.