This week's caselaw
Shaw v Kovac: Court of Appeal dismisses recusal
application
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2017/1028.html
The claimant objected to two members of the Court of Appeal
hearing her appeal and applied for recusal on the ground of
apparent bias. Both judges had been involved in earlier decisions
which had been adverse to the claimant. The claimant accepted that
that alone did not support an argument for apparent bias but it was
argued that in one decision, one of the judges had referred to a
document which she has produced as "misleading" (and so
was said to have impugned her integrity). The Court of Appeal
rejected this as a basis for apparent bias, citing earlier caselaw
in which it has been held that the mere fact that a judge has, in
an earlier case, commented adversely on a party, or found the
party's evidence unreliable, does not in itself form the basis
of a sustainable objection. For example, in Otkritie v
Urumov (see Weekly