Savash v CIS General Insurance
Fraudulent insurance claims and knowledge of the
insured
http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/TCC/2014/375.html
The insured claimed under his household insurance policy
following an alleged burglary at his home. The insurers declined
cover on the basis that the claim was fraudulent and supported by
fraudulent devices. Much of the case therefore turns on its
particular facts (Akenhead J concluding that there had been a
burglary but that the claim presented to the insurers had been
grossly exaggerated) but one particular issue is of more general
interest.
The judge raised the possibility that the insured may have
innocently passed on to his insurer fraudulent claims which had
been created by his father (although he went on to conclude that,
on the facts, this was not the case). It was accepted by the
insured's counsel that, had he recklessly adopted and pursued
deliberately exaggerated claims, he would be "guilty" of
fraudulent