Commercial Court considers issues of notification, causation,
estoppel, defence costs and set-off
Clyde & Co (Roderic McLauchlan and Sara Larmour) acted for
the defendants
The main issue in this case was which policy year claims against
a now insolvent insured fell under. Much of the case is fact
specific, but the judge, Andrew Henshaw QC, covered the following
issues, which are of general interest:
(1) Notification of a "hornet's nest"-type
situation. The judge said that notification of such a situation may
be limited where there is a requirement that the notified
circumstances are such as to suggest that a claim is likely to
arise: "Thus, to take an extreme example, a purported
notification which simply stated at a high level of generality that
the insured had performed a particular project badly in its
entirety would be likely to be ineffective as a notification, if
only because it failed to specify any particular failings or at
least categories of failing