CAUSATION
Elementary My Dear Watson? Causation And The Burden Of
Proof
By Simon Cooper and Carrie Radford
Would Sherlock Holmes have been a reliable claims handler? A
recent decision by the Court of Appeal suggests not – and
they did not think much of Hamlet either.
The Court of Appeal has had occasion twice this year to consider
the test required to discharge the burden of proof for civil
liability. Nulty v Milton Keynes Borough Council [2013]
Lloyd's Rep IR 243 involved a dispute as to the cause of a fire
at a recycling plant. Ace European Group v Chartis Insurance
UK [2013] EWCA Civ 224 concerned the cause of serious cracks
in components for an 'energy from waste facility' that was
under construction. Both appeals were dismissed because it was held
that the judges at first instance had reached conclusions that were
available to them on the facts. However, in Nulty the
Court of Appeal held that Mr Justice Edwards-Stuart had erred in
holding that if the only