Gray v Botwright
Court of Appeal considers issues of causation and apportionment
where negligence led to a "coincidence of location"
Clyde & Co for respondent
In the case of Whittle v Bennett [2006], the Court of
Appeal referred to a "coincidence of location fallacy".
In that case, A had sought to argue that, had B not been negligent
earlier on (by failing to leave an appropriate stopping distance
whilst driving), the accident in question would not have occurred
as B would not have been at that particular spot in the road when
the accident (which was not his fault) occurred. The Court of
Appeal had dismissed an argument that there should be an
apportionment of liability in such circumstances: many factors had
contributed to the fact that B had been in the particular location
when the accident had occurred (eg not having been stopped at
traffic lights earlier on, as he might have been) and the issue of
apportionment simply did not arise.