AXA General Insurance Limited and others (Appellants) v The
Lord Advocate and others (Respondents) [2011] UKSC 46
A group of leading insurance companies have failed in their
attempt to challenge the lawfulness of the Damages
(Asbestos-Related Conditions) Scotland Act 2009 ("the 2009
Act"). In their highly significant judgment published today, the UK Supreme Court
has voted unanimously to uphold the 2009 Act. The judgments provide
important discussions about the Scottish Parliament's
legislative competence, and its subjection to judicial review.
The 2009 Act allows the payment of damages to sufferers of
pleural plaques, a scarring of the lungs caused by exposure to
asbestos. Following a challenge by insurers, in January 2010 the
Court of Session accepted that as pleural plaques could lead to an
increased risk of developing mesothelioma (a tumour covering the
lining of the lung), sufferers could seek compensation (see our
January 2010
e-update).