Court assesses amount of security of costs to be
provided by a claimant
The defendants sought security for costs against the claimant,
on the basis that she is an individual resident outside the EU/EEA
(CPR r25.13(2)(a)). The Court of Appeal held that once, as here, it
had been established that there are "substantial
obstacles" sufficient to create a real risk of
non-enforcement, the starting point is the defendant should get
security for the entirety of its costs. The issue in this case was
therefore how much security it would be fair and just to order.
The defendants accepted that it was unrealistic for them to be
ordered 100% of their costs, but they sought 85-90%, on the basis
that, if the claim failed, it was very likely that costs would be
ordered to be assessed on the indemnity basis. The claimant argued
that claims for security should be on the basis of 60% of the
defendant's costs, because it was impermissible for the court
to delve into the merits of the