England's Financial Conduct Authority ("FCA") was
largely successful in its test case against eight (8)
insurers1, with respect to business interruption
coverage for infectious disease and/or prevention of access/orders
of civil authority. This test case was heard and decided by a panel
of two judges, Justice Butcher and Lord Justice Flaux of the Court
of Appeal. The decision considered 21 policy forms issued by these
eight insurers, but FCA's counsel has suggested that "some
700 types of policies across 60 different insurers and 370,000
policyholders could potentially be affected by the test
case.2"
The 150-page decision considers many issues, and notes that the
particular policy wording is important. Subtle differences lead to
potentially different results. However, there are some very
important issues decided that appear to have very broad
application.