Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 21 MAY 2014

Alarm Maintenance Obligations: Can A Policyholder Commit A Breach By Being Reckless?

The High Court held that recklessness as to fulfilment of an alarm maintenance obligation constituted breach of a condition precedent.

United KingdomInsurance
David McCarthy
David McCarthy

A recent decision of the High Court (Milton Furniture Limited v. Brit Insurance Limited) held that recklessness as to fulfilment of an alarm maintenance obligation constituted breach of a condition precedent.

The Decision

General Condition (GC) 7 provided, in part, that:

"The whole of the protections including any Burglar Alarm ... shall not be withdrawn or varied...". 

Under a separate "sweeping up" clause, compliance with GC7 was a condition precedent to the Insurer's liability.

The Claimant knew that the monitoring charge for the Burglar Alarm was payable to a security company, but failed to pay it for many months.

Mr Justice Jay concluded that by the time of the fire, the Claimant was reckless as to the risk that the monitoring service would be cut off.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from