The creditor presented a winding-up petition against the debtor company in respect of unpaid invoices under a construction contract. The debtor applied for an injunction restraining advertisement of the petition.
An interim injunction order was made, and a subsequent consent order staying proceedings was agreed stating that “UPON the agreement between the parties that there was a genuine dispute….”
The matter then returned to court, with the debtor raising disputes and counterclaims. It relied on the recital in the consent order as evidence that the creditor had accepted there was a genuine dispute.
The judge rejected this argument and, on the dispute, held that the debtor had never served any payless notices in respect of the invoices and therefore, under the contract and construction law, there was no genuine dispute to the invoices.