The long running saga of Barclays Mercantile Finance Limited ("BMBF") v Mawson reached its conclusion in the House of Lords on 25 November 2004. The final resolution of this case has brought some relief to finance lessors. What was generally perceived as an aggressive attack by the Inland Revenue on finance leasing and in particular defeased transactions has, to some extent, been curtailed.
The case is of great importance in resolving the tax treatment of a large number of existing defeased transactions. The case also provides the latest statement on the courts’ approach to the application of the "anti-avoidance" principles arising from WT Ramsay Limited -v- IRC ("Ramsay").
For those who are still unaware of the background to this case, the following is a brief outline of the relevant aspects of the structure of the transaction: