In Saad v Southampton University Hospitals NHS
Trust, the EAT has ruled that the key question for
deciding whether an allegation was made in bad faith is whether the
claimant acted honestly in making the allegation. The motives of
the claimant is making the allegation are a less relevant
consideration for the tribunal.
Mr Saad was a trainee cardiothoracic surgeon, employed by
Southampton University Hospitals NHS Trust. His employer and the
training body responsible for him had concerns about his
performance. Mr Saad raised concerns in a grievance that the
director of his training programme had made racist jokes about him,
described him as a "terrorist-looking person" and likened
him to the doctors who carried out the terrorist attack on Glasgow
airport. The grievance complained that these comments were
discriminatory on racial or religious grounds. The NHS Trust did
not uphold the grievance and Mr Saad's employment and training
were both subsequently terminated on