The Supreme Court has confirmed in Royal Mail v
Jhuti that when looking at the employer's reason,
or principal reason, for dismissal, the court can take into account
the hidden knowledge and motivations of another employee who has
manipulated the circumstances resulting in the dismissal.
Ms Jhuti made whistleblowing allegations to her line manager who
dismissed her concerns but who immediately started to performance
manage her and set unattainable targets. This led to her being off
sick and she was eventually dismissed for poor performance by
another manager who was unaware of the whistleblowing
allegations.
The EAT found that knowledge and motivation of the manipulator
should be imputed to the employer and the employer was liable for
automatic unfair dismissal for whistleblowing. The Court of Appeal
disagreed and held that an employer cannot be deemed to have
knowledge of all the facts known to its employees. That decision
follows the rationale of an earlier