Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 04 DECEMBER 2024

Rebel Without A Causal Link: HMRC's Position On Proving Carelessness

Macfarlanes LLP
Macfarlanes LLP
Contributor
Macfarlanes LLP

Macfarlanes LLP

Macfarlanes is a distinctive London-based law firm with a unique combination of services built and...

View firm profile
Explore more from Macfarlanes LLP

The Mainpay ruling clarifies HMRC must show a link between taxpayer carelessness and tax loss, though not the exact counterfactual outcome. This nuanced decision impacts penalty disputes, emphasizing the fact-specific burden of proof on HMRC.

United KingdomEmployment and HR

When HMRC rely on a taxpayer's carelessness to issue assessments and penalties, they must show the taxpayer failed to take reasonable care, but conflicting decisions have created uncertainty about whether HMRC must also show that the carelessness caused the tax loss. In Mainpay Ltd, HMRC maintained they did not have to show a causal link between the carelessness and the tax loss. However, the Upper Tribunal found that, although HMRC do not need to prove what would have happened if proper care had been taken, they do need to show a connection between the carelessness and loss of tax.

Everyone makes mistakes, but when it comes to your tax position, a 'careless' mistake can have serious consequences. If HMRC can show that a loss of tax was 'brought about carelessly' they can use the extended sixyear time limit under TMA 1970 s 36 to issue a discovery assessment. A loss of tax will be 'brought about carelessly' by a person 'if that person fails to take reasonable care

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from