Towry EJ Ltd v Bennett and others involved a
group of seven financial advisors who left Towry to join a
competitor. The financial advisers were subject to non-solicitation
covenants. In a four-month period, 429 of Towry's clients asked
to transfer their investments to the financial advisors' new
employer. Towry brought proceedings against the financial advisors
for breach of contract alleging that the seven financial advisors
had solicited these clients.
The High Court dismissed Towry's claims – there had
been no solicitation. Towry failed to establish, on the balance of
probabilities, that communications between the financial advisors
and their customers contained a material element of persuasion with
a view to gaining the business of those customers. The volume of
business lost over a short space of time to a competitor led Towry
to assume that there must have been solicitation but this was not
supported by the evidence.