Two recent TCC cases provide the answers to two important
questions relating to the termination of contracts:
- If a contractor wrongfully suspends its works, does that
conduct amount to a repudiatory breach of contract (which entitles
the employer to terminate)?
- When (if ever) will the courts grant an injunction to restrain
the (wrongful) termination of a contract?
Wrongful Suspension
In Mayhaven v Bothma, the contractor suspended its
works because it genuinely believed it had not been paid what was
due to it. As it turned out, the contractor was mistaken - it had
actually been paid what it was due. But the court held that this
was not a repudiation of the contract. The contractor had not
abandoned the project (which would have been a repudiation). It
intended to complete the works, and would have ended its suspension
if it had been authoritatively pointed out that it had been fully
paid.