In Warby v Wunda Group plc UKEAT/0434/11, Mrs Warby and
her manager had a heated exchange about what had been agreed in
previous discussions regarding her entitlement to a salary
increase. The manager denied Mrs Warby's allegation that her
wages were being changed to her detriment because of her pregnancy,
and proceeded to ask Mrs Warby why she had lied about having a
miscarriage (a view the manager formed based on a reading of Mrs
Warby's timeline on Facebook).
The EAT agreed with the Tribunal's finding that the
accusation that Mrs Warby had lied about her miscarriage did not
amount to unlawful harassment on the ground of pregnancy. In
reaching the Kemp Little LLP May 2012 decision,
the EAT emphasised that the fact that pregnancy was the subject
matter of the comments was not always enough to show unlawful
discrimination or harassment – it was important to put
the statement in context. The comment, whilst unpleasant and
offensive, was made to highlight Mrs Warby's