The Charity Commission is due to issue revised draft public
benefit guidance in March 2012 for public consultation. This
follows the withdrawal on 21 December 2011 of parts of its public
benefit guidance after a decision of the Upper Tribunal on 2
December which would have quashed those elements of the guidance
had they not been withdrawn. What might be the practical effect now
for independent schools?
Why does the guidance matter?
School governors, as charity trustees, are under a statutory
duty to have regard to the public benefit guidance when exercising
any powers or duties to which it is relevant. Clearly, therefore,
it would not be satisfactory to have to have regard to guidance
which the Upper Tribunal has found to be flawed. For this reason,
the public benefit guidance relating to fee-charging has been
withdrawn in its entirety, while all the other public benefit
guidance (including that for charities for the advancement of
education) has been amended to