Tartsinis v Navona Management Co [2015] EWHC 57
Case note posted with thanks to 7 King's
Bench Walk.
An apparently normal case – a dispute under a Share
Transfer Agreement – resulted in a very unusual outcome in
commercial litigation – a successful claim for
rectification.
Two individuals, Tartsinis and Nikolaou, agreed to sell their
shares in a company that owned a fleet of 5 ships to the Defendant
Navona – a company represented and controlled by a prominent
Greek shipowner, Kriton Lentoudis. Some time after the transaction
had closed, they sued Navona alleging that, under the STA, it owed
them $13 million.
This was on the basis of an interpretation of the STA that
looked plausible on paper, but which Navona said was not what the
parties had agreed. Navona counterclaimed on the basis that the STA
should be rectified so as to reflect their true agreement. There
were intense factual disputes about the course of the negotiations
leading up to the STA.