Originally published in Supply Management, October
2008
When negotiating contracts, make sure the provisions in the
final document are what you intended – otherwise, the
courts may end up interpreting them for you, warns Alan
Ma
Consider a situation where after months of negotiation, a
contract is finally drawn up and executed by supplier and buyer.
There is a pricing provision in the contract and the payment is
based on the supplier's performance. A dispute arises as to its
actual meaning. Literally, the supplier is entitled to a payment of
£4.6 million, but the buyer claims only £900,000 is due
based on the actual intention of the parties.
These were the underlying facts of the House of Lords'
decision on Chartbrook Limited v Persimmon Homes
(Court report, 27 August). The contract was a development
agreement such that the landowner, Chartbrook, should be entitled
to receive an excess payment if the price achieved by the developer
for each flat sold exceeded a