Tesco has won a key victory against the Competition Commission
and its proposals to make store planning applications subject to a
competition test. This is the first time that a party has
successfully challenged a market investigation remedy before the
Competition Appeal Tribunal ("the Tribunal") using the
judicial review procedure in the Enterprise Act 2002.
The competition test was proposed by the Competition Commission
following its two year investigation into the UK grocery sector.
Its aim was to prevent local markets becoming highly concentrated
(ie a small number of operators holding large shares of such
markets) and the strengthening of existing market power.
Essentially, the test would have been implemented into the
planning system obliging the local planning authority (with
specialist input from the Office of Fair Trading) to consider the
competition implications of the construction or expansion of a
large store in a local market. In other words, the