In South Africa, participating in an
unprotected strike constitutes misconduct, warranting disciplinary
action. However, item 6 of the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal
makes it clear that this does not mean that dismissal will
necessarily be justified. The Code lists several factors that may
be considered in deciding whether dismissals will be fair. One of
these factors is whether the strike was “provoked” by
the employer's conduct. If this is the case, dismissals may
be deemed unfair. But what constitutes
“provocation”?
“Provocation” as a defence
In some cases, employees have argued that their employer
provoked the strike by unilaterally changing their terms and
conditions of employment. This possibility was accepted by Zondo J
in the Constitutional Court decision in Transport and
Allied Workers Union of South Africa obo Ngedle and others v
Unitrans Fuel and Chemical (Pty) Ltd. Similarly,
in Transport & General Workers Union & others v
Coin Security Group (Pty)