It is not uncommon for employers to be confronted with
suspicious or fraudulent employee sick notes. Consequently, the
submission of such sick notes often leads to the institution of
disciplinary proceedings. Recently, the Labour Appeal Court
(“LAC”) in the case of Woolworths
v Maseko, considered the issue of
the veracity of medical sick notes and has, as a result, provided
insight into the extent of the obligations placed on employers in
this regard.
The case
The case involves an employee who submitted a medical
certificate issued by a doctor on 26 June 2018. The employer
questioned the authenticity of the sick note due to an internal
note that had been circulated within the company alleging that the
doctor had previously issued suspicious medical certificates.
Consequentially, the employer investigated the veracity of the
employee's sick note which revealed that there were some
discrepancies between the 2018 sick note and an earlier sick note
issued by the