ISSUE
Whether an employer is justified in dismissing employees
carrying weapons during a protected strike.
SUMMARY
Employees engaged in strike action who carry dangerous weapons
during a strike run the risk of dismissal. The act of carrying
weapons exposes others to the risk of injury and also serves to
threaten and intimidate others. This kind of conduct is not
protected by the right to strike.
FACTS
In the matter of Pailprint (Pty) Ltd v Lyster NO and
Others (2019) 28 LAC 1.11.47 the Labour Appeal Court
(“LAC“) had to consider the above
issue. The facts of the matter are set out briefly below.
On 1 July 2014 a number of Pailprint (Pty) Ltd
(“employer“) employees participated in
a national strike called by their union, the National Union of
Metalworkers of South Africa
(“NUMSA“). The employees were employed
in various positions at the employer’s factory. The
employer’s disciplinary code provided, among others, that the
“[b]randishing or wielding of