Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 18 JANUARY 2012

CJEU To Decide On Essential Value Of 3D Marks

One of the still unresolved questions of trade mark law is under what circumstances a shape mark is not eligible for protection because it consists of a shape that gives substantial value to the products for which protection is sought.

NetherlandsIntellectual Property
Charles Gielen
Charles Gielen
Anne Marie Verschuur
Anne Marie Verschuur

One of the still unresolved questions of trade mark law is under what circumstances a shape mark is not eligible for protection because it consists of a shape that gives substantial value to the products for which protection is sought. The CJEU touched upon this question in the Benetton/G-Star-case decided on 20 September 2007 (Case C-371/06), but did not resolve it. In its decision of 23 December 2011 the Dutch Supreme Court referred new questions to the CJEU in a case on a 3D mark registered by Revillon for chocolate products and consisting of the shape of a branch of a vine:

The case concerns an invalidation request submitted by a competitor of Revillon, arguing that the trade mark consists exclusively of a shape that gives substantial value to the goods. The Court of Appeal of Den Bosch rejected this argument on the ground that consumers would be influenced mainly by other values, such as the taste of chocolate.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from