Are Uber drivers employees or independent entrepreneurs? Dutch courts have tackled this question head-on, and their answer may surprise anyone expecting a clear-cut outcome. The dispute is a puzzle; one that must be solved piece by piece, driver by driver.
The Netherlands Trade Union Confederation (FNV) brought proceedings, arguing that Uber drivers should be classified as employees under the collective labour agreement for the taxi sector. Uber countered that its drivers are self-employed professionals. The deeper question was: how should courts approach workers who present themselves as entrepreneurs, yet whose working conditions are largely dictated by the platform?
The framework was established in the Deliveroo judgment of 24 March 2023 1. Courts must look beyond the label on the contract and weigh all circumstances holistically, including the nature of the work, organisational integration, authority, economic dependency, and genuine entrepreneurial risk.