1. Key takeaways
If any legitimate mapping of prior art onto claim features destroys novelty, the patent must be revoked (Art. 54 EPC).
When assessing novelty, the Court will examine the disclosure of the prior art document overall and will compare this disclosure to the scope of the patent-in-suit. If one way of “mapping” leads to the assessment that a piece of prior art is novelty destroying, this leads to the result that the patent must be revoked.
The Court is not bound by labels assigned to components in the prior art; what matters is the technical function the disclosed components provide.
Purpose features only require objective suitability for the intended use; they do not necessarily make referenced components mandatory parts of the claim (Art. 69 EPC).