In both Kaydee Cosmetics Limited v Elizabeth Blake and
Cedarglade Limited v Tina Hliban, the Labour Court upheld
the decision of an Adjudicator Officer to dismiss complaints of
constructive dismissal.
BACKGROUND
In Kaydee Cosmetics, the Labour Court held that, while
the behaviour of the respondent employer was imperfect and its
actions at times were 'hamfisted', it fell
'short by a considerable distance' of the bar
required for the complainant, a warehouse assistant, to succeed in
a constructive dismissal claim.
In this case issues had arisen in course of the
complainant's employment which led to the complainant being
issued with an informal warning and then a written warning. The
written warning was subsequently appealed successfully by the
complainant. The complainant was then on a period of sick leave.
Further, the respondent's business suffered a downturn and the
complainant was laid off for a period. The complainant also raised
various grievances which the