Three recent decisions spotlight the challenges employers face
in effecting mandatory retirement, as well as the price to be paid
by those who get it wrong. We will look at each case in turn and
provide some advice for employers faced with these difficult
situations.
1. Longford County Council v Michael Neilon
The Labour Court reversed a decision of the Workplace Relations
Commission (the "WRC"), finding that Longford County
Council had failed to establish that a mandatory retirement age
existed of which Mr Neilon was or ought to have been aware. Perhaps
the most striking aspect of this decision is the remedy ordered,
specifically reinstatement.
The employer's arguments
The Council compulsorily retired Mr Neilon, a truck driver, when
he reached the age of 66. Mr Neilon brought an unfair dismissals
claim. The Council argued that his retirement was in line with its
normal and agreed mandatory retirement age. The Council grounded
its position in Mr Neilon being