In its decision C-931/19 ("Titanium case"), the Court
of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") ruled that a
foreign company should not be considered as having a fixed
establishment for VAT purposes in a Member State if its activity in
that country is limited to the ownership and the exploitation of
real estate without having any human resources locally.
Consequently, a Luxembourg property company (hereafter
"PropCo"), with legal seat and place of management in
Luxembourg, owning and exploiting German real estate should not be
considered as having a fixed establishment for VAT purposes in
Germany if it does not have human resources in Germany to operate
the underlying asset.
While this court case is in continuity of settled case-law on
the concept of fixed establishment, it might have specific impacts
for Luxembourg PropCos operating German buildings, considering the
specific German administrative practice.