Foreign real estate investors in Germany may face a procedural trap when practice and case law move in different directions, revealing a gap between the letter of the law and its spirit.
In its “Titanium” ruling (C-931/19), the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) decided that a rented property, operating without the owner’s own staff, does not in itself create a fixed establishment for VAT purposes. German administrative guidance, however, still treats foreign owners of German property let on a taxable basis as “established” in Germany.
That tension can become critical during vacancy periods. In the case at hand, a Luxembourg property company holding German real estate emptied its building in late 2024 for refurbishment, expecting to resume leasing in late 2026. During 2025, it mainly incurred substantial refurbishment costs and claimed input VAT in its German monthly VAT returns.