The EPO considered determining whether a suspicious
vehicle needs to be stopped to detect a toll offence is a legal
requirement and thus non-technical. Here are the
practical takeaways from the decision T 0595/16
(Kontrollbedüftiges Fahrzeug/TOLLCOLLECT) of 14.9.2020 of
Technical Board of Appeal 3.5.05:
Key takeaways
Assigning vehicles to different groups based on specific
criteria in order to decide whether a vehicle has to be checked
manually is a business-related method and thus not
technical.
The invention
This European patent application underlying the present decision
relates to a control method for road toll collection using a
control system. Every vehicle on every road section that is
monitored by the system is to be checked by collecting usable
vehicle information. Based on these information, it is decided
whether suspicious vehicles are stopped and checked manually by
inspection staff (cf. WO 02/061690 A1, pages 1-3).