In its decision, the German Federal Labor Court (BAG) recently
distinguished between temporary and "limited" permanent
employment contracts. A permanent employment contract limited to a
particular season can be valid if there is no need for the position
outside the season and if the provision does not unreasonably
disadvantage the employee.
Facts of the case
The plaintiff had been employed by the defendant municipality as
a lifeguard since July 2000. After his employment contract was
terminated in September 2005, the parties entered into a new
employment relationship in April 2006. In accordance with the
employment contract of April 1, 2006, the plaintiff was to be
employed for the season from April 1 to October 31 of each calendar
year. The plaintiff would also only be paid during this period.
With his claim, he sought to establish that the limitation on the
employment relationship was not legally valid and that he was
permanently employed without limitation