Previous Solar Wars articles have noted that tribunals hearing
Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) claims by an investor from one EU
Member State against another EU state had consistently held that
the decision of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)
in Slovak Republic v Achmea did not apply to ECT claims.
However, on 15 January 2019, 22 EU Member States issued a
declaration intended to spell the death knell for intra-EU ECT
claims. Nevertheless, other Member States are taking a different
approach.
Achmea: a reminder
In Achmea the CJEU held that an arbitration clause in bilateral
investment treaty (BIT) between two EU states contravened EU law,
because it is for the courts of EU Member States and the CJEU to
determine questions involving EU law.