A recent judgment of the Court of Justice of the
European Union (CJEU) in the joined cases of
YouTube (C-628/18) and Cyando (C-683/19) will be
welcomed by internet service providers (ISPs) and
social media platforms. The judgment explored the degree of
knowledge of illegal activity required on the part of online
platforms before they will be unable to avail of the
“hosting defence” provided for in the
eCommerce Directive (2000/31EC). In reaching its decision,
the Court weighed up the importance of freedom of expression and
the need to balance liability of online platforms against the
fundamental rights of internet users.
Background
The cases of YouTube (C-628/18) and Cyando
(C-683/19) both originated in Germany and were subsequently
referred to the CJEU. The Court joined the cases together as
both concerned alleged infringements of intellectual property
(IP) rights by users of the video sharing
platform, YouTube, and the file-hosting and sharing