Article 69 of the European Patent Convention states that the
extent of the protection conferred by a European patent or patent
application is determined by the claims, but that the description
is nevertheless used to interpret the claims.
However, the extent to which Article 69 applies to proceedings
before the European Patent Office, which only deals with validity,
has often been debated.
In particular, the question has frequently arisen whether, and
to what extent, the description should be taken into account when
interpreting a patent claim for the purposes of assessing its
validity.
In appeal case T 439/22, the Technical Board of Appeal
identified what it saw as diverging case law on this issue. On June
24, the board referred questions to the Enlarged Board of Appeal in
referral G 1/24, seeking clarity on the role of the description in
claim interpretation at the EPO.