The addition of a secondary element, such as 'by', is
not enough to differentiate a mark from a well-known trademark even
in a different market, as Clarisse Merdy
explains in the context of a recent dispute between oil giant OMV
AG and a feminine hygiene brand.
Established in 1956, OMV AG enjoys a strong reputation in
Austria as a leading player in the oil industry and the field of
sustainable energy. In August 2021, the oil company filed an
invalidation action against the European trademark (EUTM)
"OMV! By Vagisil" (No 017980289) which had been
registered by Combe International LLC for non-medicinal products
primarily intended for feminine hygiene (classes 3 and 5).
Drawing on its earlier EUTM registrations (No 000221598 and
000221606, pictured below), OMV AG act against the disputed
registration on the following grounds: