I. Case Background
Traditional containers represent a relatively mature category in the mechanical field, where a vast amount of prior art literature exists, examination standards are stringent, the threshold for inventiveness is high, and the overall grant rate is relatively low.
The background of this case was even more unusual: the patent right granted for the parent application had been invalidated in invalidation proceedings, and the first-instance administrative litigation did not alter that outcome. Against this backdrop, the examiner relied on the same prior art references when examining the divisional application. Although the claims were amended, all claims were still found to lack inventiveness in two successive Office Actions.